data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/97d96/97d96d31bcfc611edd3de75bda3575bc263aee0e" alt="Mate translate opera"
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/2394a/2394ae00495b562e9ffac22258a485c7d7818cd1" alt="mate translate opera mate translate opera"
The San Francisco Opera production was filmed for later television relay, which occurred in late 2013. San Francisco Opera produced the opera in November 2012. San Diego Opera staged its performances in January and February 2012, with Heppner as Ahab. Calgary Opera staged the work in early 2012.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/837be/837be270e792a176aa8169e9c4fdee4810fd3cc2" alt="mate translate opera mate translate opera"
The production at the State Opera of South Australia in Adelaide followed in August–September 2011, with Jay Hunter Morris as Ahab. Duncan Osborne, the great-great-grandson of Herman Melville, was in attendance. The premiere production, directed by Foglia, featured lighting design by Donald Holder, set design by Robert Brill, costume design by Jane Greenwood and projection design by Elaine J. The Dallas Opera performances occurred from late April to mid-May 2010. Heggie specifically wrote the role of Ahab with Ben Heppner in mind. Scheer estimated that approximately 50% of his libretto used Melville's words directly. Heggie continued work on the opera in collaboration with Scheer and stage director Leonard Foglia. McNally subsequently withdrew from work on the opera because of health issues. Subsequently, Dallas Opera shared this commission jointly with San Francisco Opera, San Diego Opera, State Opera of South Australia and Calgary Opera. In consultation with Terrence McNally, Heggie suggested Moby-Dick as the subject. In 2005, Dallas Opera commissioned an opera from Heggie, intended for the company's inaugural season in the Winspear Opera House in 2010.
data:image/s3,"s3://crabby-images/97d96/97d96d31bcfc611edd3de75bda3575bc263aee0e" alt="Mate translate opera"